Categories: EditorialsOpinions

Racial justice nowhere to be found in light of court verdict

Justice for some is not justice for all. Unfortunately, those looking for immediate racial justice in the outcome of the Trayvon Martin case will have to look elsewhere.

Saturday night’s court decision, which found George Zimmerman not guilty of second-degree murder and manslaughter in the shooting death of Trayvon Martin, resulted in protests across the country. Though mostly nonviolent, these protests- illustrated clear, ideological divisions in the U.S., especially in regard to political alignment and race.

In February 2012, 17-year-old Martin was returning to his father’s fiancee’s home through a gated community in Sanford, Fla., when Zimmerman, a neighborhood watch volunteer, saw Martin. Zimmerman called police to make a report of a suspicious person and was instructed by police to stay in his car and avoid approaching Martin. Ignoring the police, he left his car and began following Martin. Moments after Zimmerman made the call to police, Zimmerman and Martin were involved in an altercation, and neighbors reported hearing gunfire.

While police were completing their report, Zimmerman admitted to shooting Martin in self-defense under Florida’s controversial “stand-your-ground” law, which allows individuals to protect themselves if they are confronted with a situation that can result in death or serious injury. Several weeks after the shooting, Zimmerman was charged with second-degree murder.

Zimmerman’s trial began June 24 with a jury of six women chosen to decide the case. After three weeks of testimony and two days of jury deliberations, Zimmerman was found not guilty of second-degree murder and manslaughter.

Because the presented evidence was anything but clear-cut, the accuracy of the ruling remains debatable. Despite the opaque ruling, people generally view this case as a racial issue. 

Both liberals and conservatives have created their own series of events based on their differing ideologies. Several liberal voices in the media appear to hold the opinion that Zimmerman attacked Martin unprovoked, while conservatives seem to believe that Martin attacked Zimmerman, who acted in self-defense.

Protests were staged in light of this court decision, bemoaning the lack of racial justice found in the result. Unfortunately, the public will not find racial justice — nor any type of ideological victory —  through criminal courts. This is simply because social progress is not a zero-sum game. 

One need not look further than instances such as Rodney King’s day in court or, on the other side of the spectrum, the wrongful celebration of O.J. Simpson’s release, to see the absence of true racial justice in our legal system.

It all boils down to one rule: One race can never truly  win over another in the court system. Instead, the imperfect system provides the public with mixed reactions and protests to highlight just how disenfranchised a group of people can feel after a criminal verdict is released.

People must stop searching for racial justice in the criminal court system and, instead, work to address a trial’s issues socially to foster true change and advocate civil rights for all.

Pitt News Staff

Share
Published by
Pitt News Staff

Recent Posts

Opinion | The dying art of going to a movie theater

But as time goes on, theaters close their doors for good, and streaming services become…

24 hours ago

The Pitt VolleyBand: The seventh player

Wisconsin volleyball fans walked into their “armory bunker,” also known as UW Field House to…

24 hours ago

SGB announces student safety, grocery store initiatives

During its weekly meeting on Tuesday at Nordy’s Place, SGB discussed new initiatives to increase…

1 day ago

Pitt Open Lab ‘I Voted’ button-making contest selects a Roc-themed winner

As the 2024 Presidential Election approached, many on-campus events took place encouraging students to participate…

1 day ago

Column | The Mike Williams redemption arc is here

Brandon Aiyuk. Davante Adams. Cooper Kupp. DeAndre Hopkins. Christian Kirk. Adam Thielen.  Name after name…

1 day ago

Opinion | The greatest tropes & cliches in media

Are we in the mood for a titillating arranged marriage and spicy there’s-only-one-bed scene? Or…

1 day ago