Opinions

Editorial: City leaders must be transparent in gun control battle

Pittsburgh City Council members Corey O’Connor and Erika Strassburger introduced a set of gun control ordinances last December, knowing full well they would violate a Pennsylvania state law that prohibits local municipalities from making their own gun laws. Over a month has passed and they are still silent about how the City plans to fight the legal battle ahead.

“At this point we are going to pass our bills, move forward,” O’Connor said to CBS Pittsburgh. “Whatever happens after that we will find out.”

Mayor Bill Peduto has similarly declined to discuss the City’s legal strategy, only hinting to CBS Pittsburgh that it would “change the discussion in Harrisburg and Washington.”

The Pennsylvania state preemption law prohibits municipalities from passing their own gun laws and has been upheld by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court since the 1990s. If City leaders hope to try their hand at overturning decades of court precedence, City residents deserve to know more about their plan than waiting to “find out.”

Pittsburgh’s effort to pass its own gun control ordinances would not be the first time local municipalities in Pennsylvania have tried to challenge the state’s preemption law. A Philadelphia assault weapons ban was struck down in 2008 and an Erie gun ordinance was also defeated in the courts in 2014.

Legal experts have expressed doubts Pittsburgh will overcome this legal precedence. In a letter to O’Connor dated Jan. 9, Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen Zappala expressed his concern the City was overstepping its legal authority.

“As the District Attorney of Allegheny County for the past 20 years, I understand the efforts to curtail gun violence and limit the accessibility to assault weapons, ammunition, and gun accessories capable of causing widespread injury, destruction, and death,” he wrote. “While I certainly see the desire for such type of legislation at the state and federal levels, I believe that City Council does not have the authority to pass such legislation.”

Peduto fired back at Zappala for suggesting the City lacked the authority to pass the ordinances and accused Zappala of threatening City leaders with criminal charges.

“Arrest me. You know what, I welcome him trying to put up a lawsuit that would arrest me if I sign this legislation,” Peduto said to CBS Pittsburgh. “It would be unprecedented simply because he doesn’t support gun reform or he is somehow so convinced the gun lobby is so important to his election that he would threaten to arrest legislators would support gun reform is astounding.”

Zappala’s letter made no indication he would arrest City leaders.

Pittsburgh faces a tough legal battle ahead if the bills are passed and City residents deserve to know how their leaders plan to overturn decades of legal precedence. Peduto’s deflections and O’Connor’s vagueness are not enough.

opinionsdesk

Share
Published by
opinionsdesk

Recent Posts

Sam Clancy: A guarantee on Pittsburgh’s Mount Rushmore

Pittsburgh is home to some of the most important figures in sports history –– so…

26 mins ago

‘I’ll get through these next four years’: Pitt students divided over Trump’s victory, with mixed emotions on campus

As the news echoes across campus, Pitt students are grappling with mixed emotions about the…

30 mins ago

Faculty Assembly discusses antisemitic violence on campus, announces antisemitic ad-hoc committee 

On Wednesday, Nov. 6., Faculty Assembly reflected on the 2024 presidential election, addressed recent acts…

33 mins ago

DePasquale, Democrat watch party brings feelings of optimism in the community

A watch party held at the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers for Pennsylvania attorney general candidate…

35 mins ago

Police blotter: Nov. 1 – Nov. 6

Pitt police reported theft by deception at The Eatery, graffiti at the Allegheny Observatory and…

35 mins ago

Blood in the water: How ‘Sharks’ became the symbol of Pitt Football

One of the biggest factors in Pitt football’s early success in 2024 is the outstanding…

46 mins ago