Categories: Archives

Editorial: Rethinking “No. 1” in class ranking

Being “No. 1” has become something of an elusive goal at an increasing number of… Being “No. 1” has become something of an elusive goal at an increasing number of suburban high schools across the United States. Some schools are altering the coveted valedictorian ranking in order to decrease pressure and fierce competition among high-achieving high school students, The New York Times reports.

Schools that support the multi-valedictorian system have found various ways to provide what they see as a more fair and equally distributed rewards system. For example, some deem any student with a 4.0 or higher as a valedictorian. Sure, such a policy takes away some of the honor — and glory — of the title, but schools that adopt this policy could bring benefits to the larger body of students.

High school students must work harder and study harder to be accepted to their preferred schools — especially if those choice schools are top tier. Assuming a school’s valedictorians have no short supply of brains, they inevitably still worked hard to achieve their rank. Yet those in competition could face burnout even if they didn’t receive the top spot or other high rank. By calling all students with straight As valedictorians, it lessens the cutthroat competition.

Schools also wrestle with factoring in weighted grades in determining ranking. Some contest a weighted grade carries an advantage while others say the class’s difficulty provides merit. Yet with multiple valedictorians, there’s potentially less scrutiny over such fine points.

Still, reporting a top rank when applying to college is one of the most tangible benefits — and that shouldn’t be taken away. Rankings should still be calculated but without all the fanfare, feuding and half-hour graduation speeches.

Pitt News Staff

Share
Published by
Pitt News Staff

Recent Posts

Opinion | The dying art of going to a movie theater

But as time goes on, theaters close their doors for good, and streaming services become…

20 hours ago

The Pitt VolleyBand: The seventh player

Wisconsin volleyball fans walked into their “armory bunker,” also known as UW Field House to…

20 hours ago

SGB announces student safety, grocery store initiatives

During its weekly meeting on Tuesday at Nordy’s Place, SGB discussed new initiatives to increase…

20 hours ago

Pitt Open Lab ‘I Voted’ button-making contest selects a Roc-themed winner

As the 2024 Presidential Election approached, many on-campus events took place encouraging students to participate…

20 hours ago

Column | The Mike Williams redemption arc is here

Brandon Aiyuk. Davante Adams. Cooper Kupp. DeAndre Hopkins. Christian Kirk. Adam Thielen.  Name after name…

20 hours ago

Opinion | The greatest tropes & cliches in media

Are we in the mood for a titillating arranged marriage and spicy there’s-only-one-bed scene? Or…

21 hours ago