Categories: Archives

EDITORIAL- “Comedy Central” good for puppets, not news

Jon Stewart, it seems, is the man of the hour. First there was his oh-so-hilarious appearance… Jon Stewart, it seems, is the man of the hour. First there was his oh-so-hilarious appearance on CNN’s “Crossfire,” where he ripped Tucker Carlson apart, bowtie and all. Then came his appearances on the covers of Rolling Stone and Newsweek, and his interview with “60 Minutes” last night

He’s this moment’s media darling — quite ironic since his career is dedicated to mocking the press that’s honoring him.

Stewart’s influence on the 18-to-30-year-old voting bloc can’t be denied. It’s the youth vote that could make or break this election. According to a CNN report, 21 percent of the viewers in that age group cite “Saturday Night Live” and Stewart’s “The Daily Show” as sources of election coverage. Twenty-three percent cited traditional news sources.

Not to knock Stewart in all his witty, sexy goodness, but it’s disturbing that almost as many young people get their news from comedy shows as they do from the regular news.

In this age where the media is derided as either aggressively liberal or pugnaciously conservative, we need to get our news not just from comedy shows, but from myriad sources.

As Stewart pointed out on “Crossfire,” his show doesn’t have the journalistic responsibility that CNN shows should, but don’t. He acknowledged this to Carlson: “You’re on CNN. The show that leads into me is puppets making crank phone calls.”

He doesn’t have to be unbiased or even comprehensive — it’s a comedy show, and a damn funny one.

Moreover, most news sources — even ones not on Comedy Central — are incomplete. We at The Pitt News, for instance, are not a national newspaper, though about 40 percent of our readers cite us as their only news source — and that’s bad.

It’s rare that a newspaper endorses its competition, but we are. We shouldn’t be the only news source for about 9,000 readers. We’re a local, community newspaper — we don’t have a Titusville news desk, much less a New York one.

So pick up another newspaper or flip through one online. Google News has an unfiltered digest of current headlines. Look through them. Piece the truth together not just by watching the local news or an hour of CNN, but also by constructing what’s going on from multiple sources.

We’re in the midst of a presidential election, one that’s focused on national security, abortion, the economy — and, oh yeah, we hear there’s a war on terrorism, or something. This is no time for ignorance or laziness. Not having time or an interest isn’t an excuse, not with media pouring in on TV, the radio, in the papers and from the Internet. Make time. Get interested.

The news might not be as funny as Stewart’s, but being an educated citizen sometimes means going beyond what is instantly accessible and, bit by bit, distilling the truth from the hype.

Pitt News Staff

Share
Published by
Pitt News Staff

Recent Posts

Pitt men’s soccer defeats Cornell, proceeds to Round of 16

On Sunday night, No. 2 seed Pitt mens’ soccer (13-5-0) defeated Cornell (13-4-2) 1-0 in…

2 hours ago

A chat with the Pitt Volleyball icon Cat Flood

On this episode of “The Pitt News Sports Podcast,” assistant sports editor Matthew Scabilloni talks…

1 day ago

Meaning at the Movies | My Old Heart & “My Old Ass”

In this edition of “Meaning at the Movies,” staff writer Lauren Deaton explores how the…

1 day ago

A Good Hill to Die On // What I Am Really Thankful For

This edition of “A Good Hill to Die On” confronts rising pressures even with the…

1 day ago

Don’t Be a Stranger | Tiny Beautiful Things

In this edition of Don’t Be a Stranger, staff writer Sophia Viggiano discusses the parts…

1 day ago

Students gear up, get excited for Thanksgiving break plans 

From hosting a “kiki” to relaxing in rural Indiana, students share a wide scope of…

3 days ago